|
Sl.
No. |
Name of the Circle |
No. of cases |
Categorisation |
Amount
awarded |
Amt. paid
+ int. if
any |
Reasons for the arbitration |
Executive lapses if any |
No. of cases in which the award in favour of department and in favour
of contractor |
Cases
challe
nged |
|
(Rs in lakh) |
|
1 |
Punjab |
8 |
Cable Duct work, construction of TE Bldg. Qrts. |
127.73 |
127.73 |
Rescinded the work and agreement cancelled |
Delayed supply of drawings/stores |
Contractor award : 7
Awaited : 1 |
1 |
|
2 |
Delhi |
2 |
Road work and building mtce. |
8.27 |
- |
Delay in completion dispute reg. Seal coat payment |
Complete revision of drawings after the original set of design etc. |
Contractor - 2 Challenged in court of law |
2 |
|
3 |
Rajasthan |
3 |
NA |
19.28 |
19.28 |
Disallowed certain items of work |
Provisional extn. Not granted, delay in supply of material, non payment
of escalation |
Contractor - 2
Party - 1 |
NA |
|
4 |
West Bengal (Assam & NE Circle) |
14 |
Cable & Building |
56.25 |
40.19 |
Non permission of local authority |
Work order issued and cancelled |
In favour of contractor. |
|
|
5 |
Tamil Nadu |
2 |
Cable |
3.88 |
3.88 |
Refund of Security Deposit and Unilateral rescinding of Contract |
Delay in obtaining permission from Municipality, Police and Highway
authorities |
In favour of contractor - 2
Challenged in Court and judgement awaited |
2 |
|
6 |
Chennai Telephones |
2 |
NA |
8.62 |
3.19 |
Delay in payment of final bill, refund of Sec. Deposit payment for open
wells and borewells |
Non release of payment to contractors |
In favour of contractor -2 |
2 |
|
7 |
Karnataka |
6 |
NA |
54.21 |
2.06 |
Claim format towards balance of work executed, increase of cost of
Construction of work executed beyond originally stipulated data,
compensation for withholding EMD, loss on cancellation of work |
Non release of payment to Contractors |
Contractor - 6 |
3 |
|
8 |
Mumbai |
7 |
NA |
16.70 |
16.70 |
Dispute for some items |
NIL |
Contractor - 7 |
NIL |
|
9 |
Orissa |
9 |
Bldg. Qrs. |
36.18 |
0.53 paid in one case |
NA |
NA |
Contractor - 9
Dept. appealed in 8 cases |
8 |
|
10 |
Gujarat |
18 |
|
17.11 |
17.11 |
Slow progress of work |
None |
Contractor - 18 |
NIL |
|
11 |
Andhra Pradesh |
4 |
|
138.11 |
1.29 paid 122.26 (deposited) |
Undue delay in change of site |
Illegal rescinding of work, delay in payment of bill delay in supply of
approved plans |
Contractor - 1 NA -3 |
NA |
|
12 |
Maharashtra |
7 |
Cable |
41.82 |
41.82 |
- |
Extra work, not handing over of site, 10 CC payments not admitted |
Contractor - 6
Department - 1 |
NIL |
|
13 |
Madhya Pradesh |
7 |
NA |
4.62 |
4.62 |
Dispute |
NA |
Contractor - 7 |
NIL |
|
14 |
Uttar Pradesh (East) |
3 |
Tower Foundation |
11.03 |
2.60 |
|
|
|
|
| |
Total |
92 |
|
543.81 |
403.26 |
|
|
|
|